Review Policy

BeautyGuide.my publishes reviews, comparisons, buying guides and product-related content to help Malaysian readers make more informed decisions about beauty products, services and treatments.

This Review Policy explains how we approach reviews, how products may be evaluated, how we distinguish first-hand testing from editorial research, and how commercial relationships are handled.

Our priority is to provide useful and transparent information rather than presenting advertising as independent editorial opinion.

Types of Review Content

Not every review or recommendation on BeautyGuide.my is produced in the same way.

Depending on the article, our content may be based on one or more of the following approaches.

Hands-On Reviews

A hands-on review means the product has genuinely been used or tested as part of our review process.

When an article is based on first-hand experience, we may discuss observations relating to matters such as:

texture and consistency
application
packaging and usability
scent, where relevant
ease of use
practical experience
advantages and disadvantages observed during use

We will not claim that a product has been personally tested when it has not.

Editorial Reviews

Some reviews may be based on editorial research rather than first-hand product testing.

This may include evaluating publicly available information such as:

product descriptions
ingredient information
manufacturer information
specifications
usage instructions
product positioning
retailer information
other relevant publicly available material

Where an article is based primarily on editorial research, we do not intend to represent that research as personal testing.

Comparisons and Buying Guides

BeautyGuide.my may publish comparisons such as:

products for a particular skin type
skincare product categories
hair-care options
makeup products
beauty tools
products within different price ranges
treatment or service comparisons

These articles may compare characteristics, intended uses, ingredients, specifications, availability and other factors relevant to the topic.

Inclusion in a comparison does not necessarily mean that every product has been personally tested.

How We Evaluate Products

The factors considered depend on the type of product being reviewed.

Where relevant, our evaluation may consider:

intended purpose
ingredient information
formulation characteristics
ease of use
packaging
suitability for different user needs
manufacturer instructions
practical advantages and disadvantages
availability in Malaysia
price and value
alternative options

Not every criterion applies to every product.

We aim to evaluate products according to factors that are genuinely relevant to the category rather than applying an identical scoring system to everything.

Beauty Products Affect People Differently

Beauty products do not produce identical results for everyone.

Experiences may vary according to factors such as:

skin type
skin sensitivity
hair type
scalp condition
allergies
existing health conditions
other products being used
individual preferences

A positive review or recommendation on BeautyGuide.my does not guarantee that a product will be suitable or effective for every reader.

Ingredients and Product Claims

When discussing cosmetic ingredients, we aim to distinguish between general ingredient information and claims made about a specific product.

We do not intentionally invent:

ingredients
ingredient concentrations
clinical study results
certifications
regulatory approvals
dermatologist endorsements
product testing results
guaranteed outcomes

Product formulations can change. Readers should check the current packaging or official manufacturer information before purchasing or using a product, particularly when ingredient information is important to them.

Reviews of Beauty Treatments and Services

BeautyGuide.my may also publish informational reviews, comparisons or guides relating to salons, beauty services, aesthetic treatments or treatment providers.

Treatment experiences and outcomes can vary substantially between individuals.

Coverage of a treatment or provider does not guarantee:

treatment suitability
safety for every individual
a specific result
a particular recovery period
permanent results
absence of side effects

Readers considering medical or aesthetic procedures should seek appropriate professional assessment where necessary.

Products Supplied by Brands

BeautyGuide.my may receive products from brands, distributors, retailers or public-relations representatives for editorial consideration.

Receiving a free product does not guarantee:

publication of a review
a positive review
a recommendation
inclusion in a buying guide
inclusion in a “best” product list

Where appropriate, relevant material relationships may be disclosed.

Affiliate Links

Some reviews, comparisons and buying guides may contain affiliate links.

If a reader makes a qualifying purchase through an affiliate link, BeautyGuide.my may receive a commission or referral fee, normally without additional cost to the reader.

The availability or size of an affiliate commission should not automatically determine our editorial conclusions.

Please read our Affiliate Disclosure for more information.

Product Rankings

Some BeautyGuide.my articles may rank or categorise products, for example:

Best Overall
Best for Beginners
Best for Oily Skin
Best Budget Option
Best for a Particular Use

Such labels represent the editorial assessment made for the particular article and criteria being considered.

They should not be interpreted as a universal or permanent ranking of every product available in the market.

Products, formulations, prices and availability can change, and articles may be updated accordingly.

Prices and Availability

Where prices are mentioned, they should generally be treated as indicative unless otherwise stated.

Prices, promotions, stock availability and product ranges can change without notice.

Readers should verify current information with the relevant retailer, manufacturer or service provider before purchasing.

Brand Requests and Corrections

Brands, manufacturers and distributors may contact BeautyGuide.my if they believe factual product information in an article is incorrect or outdated.

Legitimate factual corrections are welcome.

However, a brand’s disagreement with an editorial opinion does not automatically require us to change that opinion.

Where appropriate, factual errors may be corrected while maintaining editorial independence.

Updating Reviews

BeautyGuide.my may update reviews and buying guides when appropriate.

Reasons for an update may include:

product reformulation
discontinuation
significant price changes
changes in availability
new alternatives entering the market
inaccurate or outdated information
additional product information becoming available

An updated article may therefore differ from an earlier version.

AI and Automated Tools

BeautyGuide.my may use artificial intelligence and automated tools to assist with research organisation, content drafting, comparison structure, language improvement, quality checks and other parts of the publishing workflow.

AI assistance does not constitute product testing.

We do not consider an AI-generated description of product use to be first-hand experience.

BeautyGuide.my should never state that “we tested,” “we tried,” “we used,” or otherwise personally experienced a product unless genuine first-hand testing took place.

AI-Generated Images

Some editorial images on BeautyGuide.my may be created or enhanced using artificial intelligence.

An AI-generated image of a beauty product, treatment environment or person does not represent evidence that BeautyGuide.my has tested that product or experienced that treatment.

Where no accurate product image is available, illustrative imagery should not be interpreted as an exact representation of a specific branded product.

Editorial Independence

Brands, advertisers and affiliate partners do not automatically control our editorial conclusions.

Commercial relationships should not determine:

whether a product is recommended
the position of a product in a ranking
whether criticism is removed
whether a product receives a positive review

Our aim is to maintain a reasonable separation between commercial opportunities and editorial judgment.

Corrections and Feedback

If you believe a BeautyGuide.my review contains inaccurate product information, please contact us through our Contact Us page.

When requesting a correction, please provide:

the article URL
the product or information concerned
the information you believe is inaccurate
supporting official information where appropriate

We will review legitimate correction requests and make changes when warranted.

Our Commitment to Readers

BeautyGuide.my aims to make review content useful, transparent and responsible.

Most importantly, we will not intentionally present editorial research, manufacturer information or AI-assisted content as genuine first-hand product testing.

Readers should be able to understand the basis of our reviews and use that information as one part of their own purchasing decisions.

For more information about our overall publishing standards, please read our Editorial Policy, Affiliate Disclosure and Disclaimer.

Last updated: October 2026